Dental caries cut in half by vitamin D, review of 24 old clinical trials – Nov 2012

Vitamin D and dental caries in controlled clinical trials: systematic review and meta-analysis

Nutrition Reviews Dec 2012, DOI: 10.1111/j.1753-4887.2012.00544.x
Philippe P Hujoel
Department of Oral Health Sciences, School of Dentistry, Department of Epidemiology, School of Public Health, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington, USA

• PP Hujoel, Oral Health Sciences, Box 357475, School of Dentistry, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington 98195-7475, USA. E-mail: hujoel at uw.edu, Phone: +1-206-543-2034,

Relative rate of dental caries associated with vitamin D supplementation

Half as many caries if supplement with vitamin D

Vitamin D has been used to prevent and treat dental caries. The objective of this study was to conduct a systematic review of controlled clinical trials (CCTs) assessing the impact of vitamin D on dental caries prevention. Random-effects and meta-regression models were used to evaluate overall and subgroup-specific relative-rate estimates. Twenty-four CCTs encompassing 2,827 children met the inclusion criteria. Twenty-two of the 24 CCTs predated modern clinical trial design, some of which nonetheless reported characteristics such as pseudo-randomization (n = 2), blinding (n = 4), or use of placebos (n = 8). The relative-rate estimates of the 24 CCTs exhibited significant heterogeneity (P < 0.0001), and there was evidence of significant publication bias (P < 0.001). The pooled relative-rate estimate of supplemental vitamin D was 0.53 (95% CI, 0.43–0.65). No robust differences were identified between the caries-preventive effects of vitamin D2, vitamin D3, and ultraviolet radiation (Prob > F = 0.22). The analysis of CCT data identified vitamin D as a promising caries-preventive agent, leading to a low-certainty conclusion that vitamin D may reduce the incidence of caries.

PDF is available free at Sci-Hub   10.1111/j.1753-4887.2012.00544.x

New review associates vitamin D with lower rates of tooth decay Press Release

Studies of children in several countries linked vitamin D to a 50 percent reduction in the incidence of dental caries

A new review of existing studies points toward a potential role for vitamin D in helping to prevent dental caries, or tooth decay.

The review, published in the December issue of Nutrition Reviews, encompassed 24 controlled clinical trials, spanning the 1920s to the 1980s, on approximately 3,000 children in several countries. These trials showed that vitamin D was associated with an approximately 50 percent reduction in the incidence of tooth decay.

"My main goal was to summarize the clinical trial database so that we could take a fresh look at this vitamin D question," said Dr. Philippe Hujoel of the University of Washington, who conducted the review.

While vitamin D's role in supporting bone health has not been disputed, significant disagreement has historically existed over its role in preventing caries, Hujoel noted. The American Medical Association and the U.S. National Research Council concluded around 1950 that vitamin D was beneficial in managing dental caries. The American Dental Association said otherwise – based on the same evidence. In 1989, the National Research Council, despite new evidence supporting vitamin D's caries-fighting benefits, called the issue "unresolved."

Current reviews by the Institute of Medicine, the U.S. Department of Human Health and Service and the American Dental Association draw no conclusions on the vitamin D evidence as it relates to dental caries.

"Such inconsistent conclusions by different organizations do not make much sense from an evidence-based perspective," Hujoel said. The trials he reviewed increased vitamin D levels in children through the use of supplemental UV radiation or by supplementing the children's diet with cod-liver oil or other products containing the vitamin.

The clinical trials he reviewed were conducted in the United States, Great Britain, Canada, Austria, New Zealand and Sweden. Trials were conducted in institutional settings, schools, medical and dental practices, or hospitals. The subjects were children or young adults between the ages of 2 and 16 years, with a weighted mean age of 10 years.

Hujoel's findings come as no surprise to researchers familiar with past vitamin D studies. According to Dr. Michael Hollick, professor of medicine at the Boston University Medical Center, "the findings from the University of Washington reaffirm the importance of vitamin D for dental health." He said that "children who are vitamin D deficient have poor and delayed teeth eruption and are prone to dental caries."

The vitamin D question takes on greater importance in the light of current public health trends. Vitamin D levels in many populations are decreasing while dental caries levels in young children are increasing.

"Whether this is more than just a coincidence is open to debate," Hujoel said. "In the meantime, pregnant women or young mothers can do little harm by realizing that vitamin D is essential to their offspring's health. Vitamin D does lead to teeth and bones that are better mineralized."

Hujoel added a note of caution to his findings: "One has to be careful with the interpretation of this systematic review. The trials had weaknesses which could have biased the result, and most of the trial participants lived in an era that differs profoundly from today's environment. "

Hujoel has joint appointments as a professor in the University of Washington School of Dentistry's Department of Oral Health Sciences and as an adjunct professor of epidemiology in the UW School of Public Health. His research has concentrated on nutrition with a focus on low-carbohydrate diets, harmful effects of diagnostic radiation, and evidence-based methodology and applications.

His research has also covered sugar substitutes, the use of antibiotics in the treatment of periodontal disease, and cleft lip and cleft palate. He has also studied the link between dental disease and systemic disease, as well as trends in disease prevalence.

See also Vitamin D Life

• All items in category Dental and Vitamin D 77 items
• Vitamin D cut dental caries in half 80 years ago – meta-analysis 2013
  • analysis of this meta-analysis on Vitamin D Life
• Great Teeth if 10X more fat-soluble vitamins (Vitamin D) - 1935
• Periodontal disease 1.5 times more likely if low vitamin D – Sept 2016
• Periodontitis probably related to low Vitamin D – review June 2018
• Vitamin D may provide the most peridontal benefits of all nutraceuticals – May 2018
• Pregnancy Vitamin D levels less than 40 ng probably results in poor fetal tooth mineralization – March 2018
• Severe childhood dental problems 2.4 X more likely if breastfed for more than two years (low vitamin D) – June 2017
• Wisdom tooth (3rd molar) extraction helped by Vitamin D loading dose – RCT March 2016
• Teeth and vitamin D 2009 book -pages 105-107 describes how teeth health was known since the 1930's to be improved with vitamin D, sunshine, and full spectrum bulbs in classrooms.
• UVB added in classroom reduced cavities, increased height, increased academics. etc
• UVB and Vitamin D might decrease dental caries better than fluoride– July 2011
• Vitamin Deficiency Underlies Tooth Decay – 2009 and 1931
• Children with severe caries were 2X more likely to have inadequate vitamin D – July 2012
• Vitamin D, K2, Magnesium, etc increase bone density when taking together– Jan 2012
• More sunshine: more teeth (1862), fewer cavities (1934) – Oct 2011

Intervention AND Dental

See also web

• The Vitamin that is Better than Fluoride in Reducing Cavities Mercola Oct 2011
  Also mentions possible problem with Fluoride locking up Magnesium needed for healthy bone and teeth
• Research links vitamin D and healthy teeth American Dental Association positive review of this study
• Vitamin D and dental caries in controlled clinical trials: systematic review and meta-analysis UK, same author as this paper